Transport

Comparison of work interprocess deliveries with slider type actuators.

Comparative model

Cost

5-Year Total Cost

  • Air
    SRM3Series

    1,451,000yen

  • Electric Motion
    EBS-GSeries

    257,096yen

5-Year Total Cost Breakdown

The Electric EBS-G Series is less expensive than the Pneumatic SRM3 Series in all cost categories.

  • Air
    SRM3Series
  • Electric Motion
    EBS-GSeries
  • Product List Price of
    Component Configurations
  • 223,470
  • 117,610
  • 5-year running cost
  • 91,530
  • 5,046
  • 5-year maintenance cost
  • 1,136,000
  • 134,440
  • Total
  • 1,451,000yen
  • 257,096yen

Total Cost
Progress Graph

Compare the total cost of Pneumatic and Electric Motion over five years! !

Total Cost Progress Graph

Space

Required area

  • Air
    SRM3Series

    98,624mm^2

  • Electric Motion
    EBS-GSeries

    72,617mm^2

Actuator dimensions

The Pneumatic SRM3 Series has a large width as it has an external linear guide.
The motor part of the electric EBS-G Series is long in total length, but the required area can be reduced.

  • Air
    SRM3Series

  • Electric Motion
    EBS-GSeries

Positioning time

Positioning time

  • 0.8seconds

  • 1.31seconds

Activity Status

For Electric EBS-G, the load capacity decreases as the speed increases with the stepper motor built-in, and the Pneumatic SRM3 is shorter in positioning time. Installation time will also be shorter.

  • Air
    SRM3Series
  • Electric Motion
    EBS-GSeries
  • Positioning time
  • 0.8seconds
  • 1.31seconds

Condition

  • Air
    SRM3Series

    Actuator

    Stroke :

    500mm

    Load capacity:

    6kg

    Amount of overhang:

    50mm in the direction of the tableLoad factor:50%、Piping distance:1.5m

    Equipment
    operation

    Cycle time:

    4seconds Stop 1 sec ⇒ Travel 1 sec ⇒
    Stop 1 sec ⇒ Travel 1 sec

    Maintenance cycles:

    5 times 2,000km replacement

    Maintenance time:

    4 hours/cycle
    (charge 10,000
    yen/hour)

    Energy efficiency:

    20% (Pressure 0.5MPa)

    Cost:

    2.5yen/m^3

  • Electric Motion
    EBS-GSeries

    Actuator

    Stroke :

    500mm

    Load capacity:

    6kg

    Amount of overhang:

    50mm in the direction of the tableAcceleration/Deceleration 0.7G

    Equipment
    operation

    Cycle time:

    4seconds Stop 1 sec ⇒ Travel 1 sec ⇒
    Stop 1 sec ⇒ Travel 1 sec

    Maintenance cycles:

    Once 5,000km replacement

    Maintenance time:

    4 hours/cycle
    (charge 10,000
    yen/hour)

    Energy efficiency:

    75%

    Cost:

    24yen/kWh

Component configuration that satisfies the actuator conditions

  • Air SRM3Series
  • Required quantity
  • Electric Motion EBS-GSeries
  • Required quantity
  • Actuator
  • SRM3-32B-500-T2YH3-D
  • 1
  • EBS-08GE-200500NBN-CS03
  • 1
  • Controller
  • ECG-ANNN30-NPA00
  • 1
  • Speed controller
  • SC3W-8-6
  • 2
  • Solenoid valve
  • 4GB120R-06-E2-3
  • 1
  • Silencer
  • SLW-8A
  • 2
  • Fitting
  • GWS8-8
  • 2
  • Filter/regulator
  • W1000-8-W-F1-B3W
  • 1
  • Tube * 3 m used
  • F-1508-20-W
  • 0.15